Skip to Content

Pros and Cons of Tankless Water Heaters

Are you thinking of upgrading your water heating system? Weigh the pros and cons of tankless water heaters before making the switch!

When we bought our house, we knew the water heater was on its last legs. When it finally kicks the bucket, we plan to replace it with a fancy new tankless water heater. The dream of endless hot showers while saving both money and space is too alluring to pass up! But it pays to do your research to see if an on-demand system is right for your home. Luckily, I've already weighed the pros and cons of tankless water heaters for you!

This post contains affiliate links for your convenience. If you would like to learn more about how you can support this site at no cost to you, please visit my disclosures page.

How Does a Tankless Water Heater Work?

A tankless water heater is basically a heat exchanger connected to your home's plumbing system. When someone open up a hot water faucet, it turns on the heating unit. This unit may be gas or electric, but they perform the same task.

Water runs through the heat exchanger which heats the water to the desired temperature before delivering it to the faucet. There is almost no lag time before the water is hot, just like magic! When the faucet is closed, the heater shuts off.

Here's an infographic of a guy taking a shower in his underwear to illustrate the on-demand system. 🙂

One of the benefits of a tankless water heater is that you never run out of hot water!

Pros and Cons of Tankless Water Heaters

Pros

  • Hot Water Won't Run Out
    • Imagine long, hot showers without your significant other banging on the door to remind you not to use all the hot water! Or filling up a bathtub without a layer of cold water on top. You can also shower while the dishwasher or washing machine are running without it turning to ice when the rinse cycle starts!

One of the pros to tankless water heaters is never running out of hot water for your shower!

  • Energy Efficiency
    • With no holding tank full of water kept at a certain temperature at all times, it wastes less energy. A tankless unit only operates when it's called upon.
  •  
  • Saves Space
    • We would have loved a tankless water heater in our old condo, where a huge tank took up half a closet that could have been used for more storage! The entire on-demand system is mounted on the wall to save you tons of floor space.
  • Less Chance of Water Damage
    • Another consideration in favor of going tankless is that there is less chance of water damage if something should happen to the unit. No tank to crack means none of this...

One of the benefits to a tankless water heater is never having to worry about a water tank leak!

Cons

Although tankless water heaters appear to be the perfect answer for supplying your home with hot water, there are some downsides to them as well.

  • Price
    • Even though prices are dropping, tankless units can still be expensive. They can run anywhere between $500 to over $1,000 depending on heating capacity.
    • If you live in a cold climate, you'll need a more powerful heating element to bring the water in your pipes up to your desired temperature. More power = more expensive. To get an idea of the typical ground temperature of your area, check this map.
The heating capacity of your tankless water heater depends on the ground temperature of your pipes.

Photo courtesy of EcoSmart


  • Installation
    • If you are converting to a tankless water heater, the installation can add considerably to the cost since it may require rerouting gas or electrical connections.
    • Finding a professional to install the system can be tricky. Check with your local plumbing company or even try Amazon Home Services.to see if they have someone who is familiar with the process.
  • Building Codes
    • You should also check building codes in your area before purchasing a tankless unit since many areas require mounting them on external walls only, limiting where you do an installation and complicating the requirements for gas or electrical connections.

I hope this clarifies some of the pros and cons of tankless water heaters for you. Now you can feel confident in your decision about whether this type of system works for you and your home!

If you would like to keep up to date with my latest posts about home improvement and more, you can follow me on FacebookPinterest, or sign up for my weekly newsletter below.

Want more DIY projects?

Subscribe to get project ideas, home improvement tips, woodworking plans and more delivered straight to your inbox!

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit

Thinking of upgrading your home's hot water system to tankless? Do your research first and weigh the pros and cons of tankless water heaters!

 

Frani

Thursday 2nd of March 2017

Your timing is perfect!!!! We are about to take the plunge and do so appreciate all this information! Thank you!!!

Kristi Cathey

Wednesday 1st of March 2017

It's true that everything has two sides. Although it costs a little bit much, it has many advantages and I'm fine with the cost. Anyway, you did a great research. Thanks!

Ariel

Tuesday 28th of February 2017

we've got one in our rental and quite like it actually!

Janine

Monday 27th of February 2017

Since visiting Europe a couple of times, I have so wanted a tankless water heater. Well, maybe our next home we will have one installed. This is so helpful!

vicky

Sunday 26th of February 2017

We installed a tankless propane hot water heater 8 years ago. We live in one of the areas the above map shows a 42F ground temperature. I would never go back to a tank. It's never missed a beat.

Vineta

Sunday 26th of February 2017

Part of me hopes our tank dies soon so we can put in a tankless! Glad to hear yours is going strong after 8 years!

Comments are closed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.